Where did Valentine's Day come from? Should Christians celebrate it?

featured article image

TL;DR:

Valentine’s Day has mixed origins from Christian martyr stories and possible pagan traditions, but the Bible doesn’t mention it specifically. Christians can choose to celebrate Valentine’s Day if their focus reflects God-honoring love, purity, and selflessness, rather than lust or selfishness.

from the old testament

  • The Bible doesn't mention Valentine’s Day directly, since it developed many centuries after the biblical texts were written. However, both the Old and New Testaments offer important principles about love, honoring others, and the purity of relationships that help Christians reflect on how (and whether) to celebrate Valentine's Day. For example, Genesis 2:18 and 2:24 shows God’s design for marriage and committed love.
  • A poetic celebration of romantic love between a bride and groom is expressed in Song of Solomon (especially chapters 1-8). It shows love, desire, and delight in marriage as something good and God-honoring.
  • Proverbs 5:18-19 encourages faithfulness, joy, and affection within marriage.
  • Exodus 20:14 and Deuteronomy 5:18 reminds us that God's standard for love includes moral purity and faithfulness.

from the new testament

  • First Corinthians 13:4-8 defines true, selfless love (agape), which applies to all relationships, not just romantic ones.
  • Ephesians 5:25, 28, 33 tells us how we are to love within marriage: “Husbands, love your wives, as Christ loved the church and gave himself up for her” (v.25).
  • All love comes from God, and our love for others is an overflow of His love for us (1 John 4:7-12).
  • Romans 12:10 encourages believers to show genuine care and respect in all relationships and not just on Valentine’s Day: “Love one another with brotherly affection. Outdo one another in showing honor.”
  • Philippians 4:8 helps us evaluate whether our Valentine’s Day celebrations align with what is godly and wholesome: “Whatever is true, honorable, just, pure, lovely… think about these things.” If Valentine’s Day is about loving others well, then we can celebrate it, but if it promotes lust or selfish desires, we should reconsider how we observe it to ensure our hearts and actions honor God

implications for today

The origin of Valentine's Day is unclear. February 14 is listed on the Calendar of Saints in both the Anglican and Lutheran churches. The Roman Catholic Church no longer lists Saint Valentine's Day on its official calendar and, instead, has made it a local celebration. The Eastern Orthodox Church celebrates Saint Valentine's Day but in July. There are several Saint Valentines associated with February 14, but it seems the tradition revolves largely around Valentine of Rome.

Valentine of Rome is said to be a Christian martyr, killed on February 14, 496 under the direction of Emperor Claudius II of Rome. Several stories about his persecution exist. One is that during general persecution of Christians, Valentine of Rome was interviewed personally by Emperor Claudius II for sentencing. Evidently Claudius II was impressed by Valentine and offered that if Valentine converted to paganism his life could be spared. Rather than convert, Valentine is said to have attempted to convert Claudius to Christianity, thus earning himself the death penalty. Prior to his execution, Valentine is thought to have performed a healing miracle for the jailer's blind daughter, Julia. In some renditions, Valentine wrote a letter to Julia prior to his execution, signed "Your Valentine."

Another tradition suggests that Valentine performed weddings for soldiers who had been prohibited from marrying by rule of Emperor Claudius II based on the belief that single men make better soldiers. Valentine was jailed and supposedly those whom he had married passed him notes and flowers in jail. Also while in jail he fell in love with the jailer's daughter. Prior to his execution he is said to have written her a love letter signed, "Your Valentine."

There is also a tradition that Valentine gave hearts made of parchment to soldiers and persecuted Christians, reminding them of their vows as well as God's love. Some have linked Valentine's Day to a celebration of the beginning of spring. Others have suggested that Valentine's Day has pagan roots and is associated with Lupercalia, a February pagan holiday centered on fertility and love. Others say that the connection between Valentine's Day and romance did not come about until the fourteenth century with the English poet Chaucer's writings.

The modern celebration of Valentine's Day as a romantic holiday that includes exchanging of cards, chocolates, and flowers likely came out of England and developed fairly recently. Commercialized Valentine's cards came about in the early to mid-nineteenth century. In the latter portion of the twentieth century, giving gifts became popular. The celebration of Valentine's Day has extended from England to the Anglosphere and beyond. For many, both single and married, Valentine's is simply a day to express love to all manner of friends and family. Nothing is inherently wrong with expressing love through cards and gifts on a specific day of the year. But nothing is inherently righteous about it either, as we should express our love for one another throughout the year and in a variety of ways. While there is no such thing as "Sainthood" in the terms meant by the Catholic Church, there is certainly nothing wrong with commemorating Christian martyrs or faithful Christians of the past. But neither is there a biblical mandate to do such things. The holiday is neither biblical nor anti-biblical. Christians can apply the principles found in Romans 14:5, "One person esteems one day as better than another, while another esteems all days alike. Each one should be fully convinced in his own mind."

understand

  • Valentine’s Day has uncertain origins that blend Christian martyr stories with possible pagan traditions and later medieval romantic influences.
  • The Bible provides clear principles on love, purity, faithfulness, and honoring relationships that guide how Christians should approach celebrations such as Valentine’s Day.
  • Whether Christians celebrate Valentine’s Day or not, they should seek to uphold God-honoring love rather than selfishness or lust.

reflect

  • How do your current Valentine’s Day traditions reflect God’s design for love, purity, and faithfulness?
  • How do you express love to others that go beyond romantic gestures and reflect God’s selfless love?
  • How can you approach Valentine’s Day in a way that isn’t driven by culture or lust?

engage

  • How can Valentine’s Day become an opportunity for Christians to show Christ-like love—not just to a spouse or significant other, but to friends, family, or the lonely?
  • What are the dangers of uncritically adopting cultural traditions like Valentine’s Day, and how can we evaluate them in light of biblical principles?
  • How can the church help believers discern the difference between cultural expressions of love and biblical love?