What happens in a papal conclave?

featured article image

TL;DR:

The papal conclave is a centuries-old tradition of electing a pope, but the office of pope itself is not found in the Bible. Scripture teaches that Jesus Christ alone is the head of the Church and its foundation.

from the old testament

  • God alone appoints leaders for His people. In Israel’s history, God raised up leaders such as Moses (Exodus 3:10), Joshua (Joshua 1:1-2), and the judges (Judges 2:16). Leadership was by God’s calling, not by human election or ceremony.
  • Kings were chosen and anointed by God’s direction. Saul and David were both anointed as kings under God’s command (1 Samuel 10:1; 16:12-13), not by human councils.
  • Even when He allowed human leaders, God reminded Israel that He alone is their ultimate ruler (Psalm 23:1; Isaiah 40:11).
  • Indeed, one of Israel’s sins was seeking a human leader despite having the Perfect Leader in God (1 Samuel 8:4-9)

from the new testament

  • The papal conclave isn’t in itself unbiblical, but the office of Pope is not found in Scripture. Roman Catholics believe the Bishop of Rome follows a direct succession from the Apostle Peter based on Matthew 16:18: “And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it” (emphasis added). While Jesus’ statement could have meant Peter would be the foundation for the church, it does not follow that Peter was a bishop of Rome or that the Roman Catholic claims are valid.
  • The Bible makes clear that Christ is the head of the church (Ephesians 1:22-23; Colossians 1:18). The papal conclave may be an interesting spectacle, but it does not identify God’s choice for the head of His church on earth, since that role belongs to Jesus alone.

implications for today

The papal conclave was developed over many centuries to limit the issues inherent in papal succession. In 1059, the electoral body was limited to the College of Cardinals, or the group of all cardinals in the church. This helped some, but in 1274, Pope Gregory X found it necessary to enact further restrictions. To prevent lengthy deadlocks, he decreed that the bishops would be under lock in a secluded conclave in the Sistine Chapel—"conclave" comes from the Latin cum clave, or "with key"—until they had agreed upon a successor. In 1970, Pope Paul VI restricted the electoral body to those under eighty years old. In addition, two-thirds of the conclave's vote is required to elect a new pope.

Current papal conclaves are regulated by Pope John Paul II's Universi Dominici Gregis. It covers the responsibilities of the College of Cardinals during the papal vacancy, the funeral arrangements of the deceased pope, a description of who is eligible to determine the next pope, and the procedures for doing so. Subsequent popes have made minor changes since the 2007 Universi Dominici Gregis. The Cardinals are housed in a dormitory-style building separate from the Sistine Chapel, and both the timing of the conclave and the procedures for the coronation of the new pope are more flexible. Additionally, any non-cardinal who reveals what has happened in the conclave may be excommunicated.

A papal conclave begins with security sweeps and a sermon on the Church’s needs. The cardinals celebrate the Eucharist, process to the Sistine Chapel, and take oaths of secrecy before outsiders are expelled. After procedural instructions, voting begins—one vote on the first day, then up to four daily, with days of prayer and dialogue if no result is reached. Ballots are sworn, cast, and burned, with smoke signaling the outcome. Once a candidate accepts, he chooses a papal name, dons vestments in the "Room of Tears," and is presented to the public at St. Peter’s Basilica.

The papacy is a lifetime appointment. The vast majority of popes die in their position. Pope Benedict XVI, who stepped down in 2013 due to poor health, was the first pope to resign since Gregory XII in 1415.

understand

  • The papal conclave is the Roman Catholic Church’s process to elect a new pope.
  • The papal conclave prevents political interference and ensures orderly succession of the pope.
  • The office of pope is not biblical; Jesus alone is the head of the Church.

reflect

  • How does knowing that Jesus alone is the head of the Church affect the way you view human-led church leadership?
  • Where do you need God’s guidance rather than relying on human authority in your life?
  • How can understanding the papal conclave process give better perspective to the Roman Catholic tradition?

engage

  • How do we see God’s sovereignty in the appointment of leaders in the Bible, and what does that teach us about His character and involvement with humanity?
  • How might human traditions, even long-standing ones, both help and distract from recognizing Christ as the head of the Church?
  • How can we encourage one another to seek God’s guidance first when evaluating leadership within the Church today?