Who wrote 2 John?

Who wrote 2 John?
Redemption The Bible New Testament

TL;DR:

Second John identifies its author as “the elder,” traditionally understood to be the apostle John. His letter calls believers to walk in truth and love while guarding against false teachings about Jesus.

from the old testament

  • The book of 2 John is not found in the Old Testament.

from the new testament

  • Second John identifies its author as “the elder” (2 John 1). This parallels 3 John 1, which identifies its author the same way. Thus, there is strong reason to believe the same individual wrote both letters.
  • The traditional view holds that the “elder” is a self-reference by the apostle John later in his life, consistent with the age of these letters, believed to have been written in the 80–90 ADs. The primary argument against the apostle John is that John doesn’t identify himself as elder (or another name) in the Gospel of John or 1 John, meaning these letters begin differently. Additionally, a fourth-century quote from a man named Papias implies that a second John lived in the same region and was known as “John the elder.”
  • Despite those suggestions, we must give more weight to the internal evidence- the evidence within the letter itself. Second John includes several themes that strongly resemble 1 John.
  • 2 John 7says, “For many deceivers have gone out into the world, those who do not confess the coming of Jesus Christ in the flesh. Such a one is the deceiver and the antichrist.” Likewise, in 1 John, the author says many had left the believing community (1 John 2:19), deceiving those left behind (1 John 2:26), whom John calls “antichrist” (cf. 1 John 2:18–22). The author of 1 John also urges readers to test them, saying that anyone who does not confess that Jesus came in the flesh is not from God (1 John 4:2).
  • Like the author, “the elder” also tells his readers to “love one another” and “walk according to his commandments” (2 John 5b–6). This sounds similar to 1 John’s “message that you have heard from the beginning, that we should love one another” (1 John 3:11) and “this is his commandment, that we believe in the name of his Son Jesus Christ and love one another, just as he has commanded us” (1 John 3:23).
  • Finally, in both cases, the author’s joy is tied to whether the believers were walking in accordance with the commandments (2 John 4; cf. 1 John 1:3–4).
  • Therefore, the same author likely wrote both. Unfortunately, 1 John does not state its author. However, 1 John shares many similarities with the Gospel of John, which is why tradition holds that the same author wrote 2 John. The Gospel of John is attributed to the apostle John; therefore, the apostle also wrote 2 John.

implications for today

In 2 John, perhaps a personal letter (though scholars debate whether “the elect lady” was a woman or a church), John commends them for walking in the truth, while reminding them that those who left, as he also said in 1 John, were “antichrists,” working against the truth.

John’s warnings in 2 John apply to us, as well. While our situations are different, we are also surrounded by false religions calling themselves “Christian” while denying core truths about Jesus. Just a few common examples include Mormons (LDS) and Jehovah’s Witnesses. They “evangelize” by going door to door and standing on street corners, leading people away from Jesus by their false teaching. John warned that we should not welcome people like that. He didn’t mean that we should be hostile to them. He meant we should never greet them as one greets a brother or sister in Christ, so we don’t appear to endorse their teaching. Not doing that both protects us and warns others who may be watching that the Jesus they talk about isn’t the Jesus who can save them.

understand

  • Second John identifies its author only as “the elder,” the same self-identification used in 3 John, suggesting both letters were written by the same person.
  • The thematic similarities between 2 John and 1 John—the antichrist figure, the command to love, and the joy of believers walking in truth—strongly suggest that the same author wrote both letters.
  • "The elder" is traditionally understood as John’s humble self-reference late in his life.

reflect

  • How are you balancing love for others with standing firm in the truth about Jesus?
  • How can you become better at recognizing teachings that distort who Jesus is?
  • How does John’s humble title, “the elder,” challenge the way you view leadership and recognition?

engage

  • What evidence connects 2 John to 1 John and the Gospel of John, and how convincing do we find it?
  • Why is it important for us to hold firmly to the truth about Jesus while still treating those who disagree with us with love and respect?
  • How can we protect our church community from false teaching without becoming unwelcoming or unkind to others?