Is consubstantiation biblical?

TL;DR

Consubstantiation teaches that Christ is spiritually present in Communion without the bread and wine becoming His literal body and blood. While Christians disagree on this view, we can agree on the fact that Jesus died once for all.

WHAT DOES THE BIBLE SAY?

At the Last Supper, Jesus instituted the New Covenant with bread and wine, calling the bread His body (Matthew 26:26; Mark 14:22; Luke 22:19) and the wine His blood (Matthew 26:27–28; Mark 14:23–24; Luke 22:20). There are three views of what He meant: memorial, transubstantiation, and consubstantiation.

Transubstantiation holds that the bread and wine literally become Jesus’ body and blood while maintaining their appearance. However, Scripture teaches that Jesus died once and does not need to be sacrificed again (Hebrews 9:28; 10:10–14). Additionally, the Roman Catholic Church's elevation of the elements led to them being withheld from everyday Christians for fear they’d profane Jesus’ body.

Consubstantiation was Martin Luther’s reaction to transubstantiation. He wanted to keep a mystical understanding of Jesus’ words without the theological problems of transubstantiation. He argued (as Lutheranism still does) that Jesus’ body and blood are spiritually present “in, with, and under” the elements.

Because consubstantiation avoids transubstantiation’s theological errors, it’s not unbiblical. However, Protestants both in Luther’s day and today disagree with it, noting that Jesus called the act a remembrance (Luke 22:19; 1 Corinthians 11:24–25). Their view is called the memorial view, as it holds that the symbols merely memorialize what Jesus did.

While believers disagree on the accurate understanding of consubstantiation and the Lord’s Supper, let us charitably agree to disagree with faithful believers on this point!

FROM THE OLD TESTAMENT

FROM THE NEW TESTAMENT

IMPLICATIONS FOR TODAY

We need to be careful in how we put the various spiritual disciplines into practice. In the Roman Catholic Church, they began worshipping them and treating them as if they were Jesus. While consubstantiation was a corrective, it still has a mystical element that can lead one’s imagination, if they are not careful, to arrive at theologically shaky conclusions about the nature of Jesus or the special act of taking Communion versus remembering that the focus is not on the elements but on what they point towards.

Genuine Christians disagree on whether Jesus is somehow actually present with the elements, or whether consubstantiation misses the symbolic nature of Jesus’ teaching. Therefore, we must be careful not to assume bad motives on either side. What is clear from the Lord’s Supper is that it is reserved for believers (1 Corinthians 10:16–17; 11:27–29) and commemorates the New Covenant, which would come through His blood (Luke 22:20). Let us treat the elements, then, as the means through which we remember and thank Jesus for what He has done.

Also, let us remember that, while somber, the Lord’s Supper is not a funeral service! It reminds us that Jesus is returning, when He will again drink the fruit of the wine with us (Matthew 26:29; 1 Corinthians 11:26) at His banquet (Luke 22:29–30; cf. Revelation 19:9).

Therefore, when you take communion, remember Jesus’ command: “Do this in remembrance of me” (Luke 22:19).

UNDERSTAND

REFLECT

ENGAGE