Is pastoral restoration possible after a pastor has been involved in a scandal?Can a pastor involved in a scandal later be restored to ministry? A look at the New Testament reveals that the key concern is related to whether the pastor can continue to meet the requirements of an elder/pastor as found in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1.
In both of these passages, an elder must be above reproach. This includes being known as a "one-woman man," not being violent, not working for financial gain, and other related qualities. Depending on the type and magnitude of the pastor's scandal, reaching this level of integrity may or may not be possible.
For example, if a pastor has been removed from leadership due to adulterous relationship, he would not be known for being a "one-woman man" for several years, if ever. If a pastor was involved in a large financial scandal, it is unlikely he would soon regain trust among fellow believers, indicating that any restoration to pastoral ministry would be years in the future or perhaps not at all.
An important distinction should be made, however, between restoration as a pastor and restoration to the church. If a pastor has been involved in a scandal and then repents, he is to be forgiven and embraced as a brother in Christ. However, this does not mean he is ready to serve in church leadership again. Rebuilding trust takes time, especially if the situation was ongoing or very public.
Further, some churches or denominations have specific rules regarding the restoration of a minister. These would also need to be taken into consideration when considering the restoration of a pastor who has been involved in a scandal.
But can a pastor caught in a scandal ever be restored to ministry? Certainly there are some cases in which a pastor's sin will be followed by a period of rebuilding trust and integrity that lead a congregation to accept him as a leader again. The key issues involved are the nature and magnitude of the pastor's scandal and his way of life following the scandal.
A congregation may find that a pastor who was involved in some sort of scandal many years ago has since repented and shown evidence of change over many years of time that has once again qualified the person for consideration in ministry. In these cases, it is the local church's role to consider the information, pray, and make a godly choice regarding what would be best for their particular church.
What was God's purpose in establishing the church?
What qualifications does the Bible give for elders and deacons?
Why are there so many evangelical Christian scandals? Why are so many evangelical leaders caught in scandal?
Does the Bible talk about church government?
What duties are church elders responsible for?
Truth about Church