Is emotional abuse a valid reason for divorce?

Is emotional abuse a valid reason for divorce?
Fall Sin

TL;DR:

Emotional abuse is never God’s design for marriage, and while the Bible does not list it as a specific ground for divorce, it does not require victims to silently endure abuse. Seek safety, wise counsel, and justice while remembering that real repentance means changed actions—not just apologies.

from the old testament

  • God created Adam and Eve to be joined together for a lifetime: "Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and they shall become one flesh" (Genesis 2:24). Jesus later points to this to show the significance of marriage and the rare circumstance under which divorce can occur (cf. Matthew 19:4-9).
  • God has made provisions for divorce in the Mosaic Law but that was because of their sinfulness, not because He approved of divorce (Deuteronomy 24:1-4; cf. Matthew 19:4-9).
  • God takes the marriage covenant seriously because He likens it to His covenant with His people (Ezekiel 16:8; Malachi 2:14-16).

from the new testament

  • Jesus made it clear that divorce was not God's intent, even though He allowed regulated it in the Mosaic Law: "Because of your hardness of heart Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so" (Matthew 19:8). Jesus then indicates adultery as the criterion for divorce: "And I say to you: whoever divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, and marries another, commits adultery" (Matthew 19:9).
  • The Holy Spirit later reveals, through Paul's letter to the Corinthians, that an unbelieving spouse abandoning a believing spouse is also grounds for divorce (1 Corinthians 7:15).
  • That said, any sort of abuse—-emotional or physical—is not God's plan for marriage. Spouses are to show sacrificial love to one another, a love that is patterned after Christ's love for the church (Colossians 3:19; Ephesians 4:31-32, 5:25-29).
  • An abused spouse has the right to protect herself/himself and the children and to get the help of the governing authorities God has put in place to administer justice (Romans 13:3-4). The Holy Spirit discusses circumstances in which a spouse leaves an abusive relationship for protection, even if divorce is not the outcome (1 Corinthians 7:10-11).

implications for today

Playground taunts hurt. Bullies' cruel comments can stay with their victims into adulthood. But bullies don't always grow out of their cruelty. Sometimes, sadly, they marry and continue their bullying, but this time to their spouse and, sometimes, their children. Emotional abuse might involve demeaning comments, controlling behavior, intimidation, manipulation, and more. At times, emotional abusers might even use Scripture to control their spouses.

It's not what God intended marriage to be.

An abused spouse should seek the counsel of his or her church leadership and any legal protection available.

A spouse who is truly repentant will show that by a willingness to take action, not just say they’re remorseful. Abusers who want to change can do so if they’re willing to submit to God’s way—but the abused spouse is not responsible for changing them. If you are experiencing emotional abuse, remember that loving your spouse does not mean enduring sin silently; seek wise, godly counsel, establish appropriate boundaries, and take the steps necessary to protect yourself and your children. God loves you and is for you and your marriage.

understand

  • The Bible presents two circumstances in which God permits divorce: adultery and abandonment.
  • God commands spouses to exhibit a self-sacrificing love toward one another; an abusive spouse is in rebellion against God.
  • Abused spouses should seek safety and justice from the governing authorities God has set up.

reflect

  • What do you find challenging about the reality that God only gave two explicit situations that count as grounds for divorce?
  • How could you support fellow believers who are in abusive marriages?
  • How does the Bible’s high view of marriage challenge the way you think about commitment, faithfulness, and your choice of a spouse?

engage

  • What warning signs of controlling or emotionally abusive behavior should Christians learn to recognize before or after entering into marriage?
  • How can we support someone experiencing emotional abuse while also upholding the biblical seriousness of the marriage covenant?
  • How does Christ’s sacrificial love provide a standard that exposes the selfishness and control involved in emotional abuse?