John was writing
to a community of believers involved in a type of “church split” where one
portion left, teaching a different Gospel (1 John 2:19). The specifics of the
false teaching are unclear but involved the denial of truths about Jesus, such
as being really human (1 John 4:2–3) and the Son of God (1 John 2:22–23), as
well as a denial of the efficacy of Jesus’ death to save (1 John 5:6). The
false teaching confused the believers, causing them to be lax in their
obedience (1 John 2:4–6) and downplaying their sin (1 John 1:8–10). The result
of all of that was that they had lost assurance of their salvation.
John wrote to remind
them that he personally knew Jesus (1 John 1:1–3) and thus the Jesus he had
taught was the true one. He explained that the others left because they were
never true believers (1 John 2:19) and they were to have nothing to do with
them (1 John 4:1). Instead, they were to obey Jesus (1 John 2:3–6), as
demonstrated through love of one another (1 John 4:7). Such obedience would help assure them of their faith (1 John 5:13).
As believers, we
might struggle with assurance. However, 1 John teaches us that a lack of assurance is often
connected with poor doctrine and a lack of active obedience. As we remember why
we are saved (through Jesus alone) and as we see evidence of a desire to obey
Him, our assurance will grow.
We all want confidence—something solid enough to stand on without constantly second-guessing it. And we can have assurance in our salvation. But assurance in our faith grows fragile when truth gets blurry and our lives drift from what we believe.
In 1 John, the issue wasn’t just doubt; it was drift. False teaching distorted who Jesus is and what He accomplished, and once that foundation cracked, obedience followed the collapse. The same pattern still happens today: when our view of Jesus weakens, our confidence in Him weakens too.
That’s why assurance is often more connected to direction than emotion. If someone claims to love coffee but always chooses tea, their actions eventually expose the disconnect, and the same is true spiritually. When we confess Christ but continually make peace with sin, we shouldn’t be surprised when confidence starts to erode.
The answer is not to try harder to feel certain but to return to what is certain. We rest again in the truth that we are saved because of Christ’s righteousness, not ours, and we are kept by His finished work, not our fluctuating performance. At the same time, real faith doesn’t stay passive—it fights sin, even imperfectly, by the power of the Spirit. It remains grounded in God. The trajectory of our lives is toward Christlikeness, staying on mission to reflect Him to a world that desperately needs Him.
Assurance grows in that tension: resting fully in what Jesus has done while actively walking in what He commands. Confidence in salvation is strengthened where sound doctrine and Spirit-empowered obedience meet.