How should a Christian view Harry Potter?

How should a Christian view Harry Potter?
Fall Culture

TL;DR:

Harry Potter can be enjoyed as a fantasy story about good versus evil, but its use of occult themes gives many Christians pause. Harry Potter does give a powerful picture of redemption, but we need to seek God for how we can honor Him with our entertainment choices.

from the old testament

  • The use of the word witchcraft in Harry Potter is problematic, as it has occult connotations. The Bible condemns the practice of the occult, witchcraft, sorcery, and spiritism (Deuteronomy 18:10–12), including contacting the dead and casting spells.
  • Parents should be concerned about the books, movies, and other media their children consume. Parents’ goal should be to raise godly children: “Train up a child in the way he should go even when he is old he will not depart from it” (Proverbs 22:6).

from the new testament

  • Parents know their children best, so they can decide if something is harmful for them (Romans 14). In this, as in all matters, we should ask God for wisdom (James 1:5).
  • Paul exhorts fathers to “bring them [children] up in the discipline and instruction of the Lord” (Ephesians 6:4). This may mean avoiding certain content that secular society promotes.
  • Acts records new believers burning their books of “magic arts” because they wanted no part of the occult after coming to Christ; they valued walking in God’s way more than the monetary worth of those books (fifty-thousand pieces of silver) (Acts 19:19).

implications for today

A child’s imagination is precious and usually, not a matter of concern. C.S. Lewis once said, "it is a great mistake to suppose that children believe the things they imagine." This quote holds true for any fiction story. If a child enjoys playing witches and wizards because of Harry Potter, this is not an immediate cause for alarm—just as you wouldn’t be concerned if your child was pretending to be a knight slaying a dragon.

But portrayals of the occult in Harry Potter may give parents pause. One of many reasons that parents should regularly study the Bible with their children is to combat the influence of secular society. If children know from family and church Bible studies that God forbids occult practices, they’ll evaluate fictional content portraying the occult, like Harry Potter.

At the same time, reading Harry Potter, as well as other literature, can provide great opportunities to talk about the themes present in the book and to help children understand the content from a biblical perspective. In the case of Harry Potter, there is a very strong type of Jesus as well as themes of resurrection and love that conquers evil, which can open meaningful conversations about Christ’s ultimate sacrifice and true redemption. At the same time, there can be conversations about the differences between fictional magic and the real power of God.

Parents who know that their children enjoy the kind of fantasy reading Harry Potter represents can introduce them to some of C.S. Lewis’ and J.R.R. Tolkien's literature. While parents can’t protect their children from all secular content, nor should they, they can equip them to revere God and the truths He lays out in His Word.

understand

  • Christian parents are cautious of Harry Potter because it portrays witchcraft attractively.
  • Parents are called to ground their children in the Bible to discern secular influences.
  • Parents should seek God’s wisdom when deciding what entertainment their children engage with.

reflect

  • What guidelines do you follow when deciding what secular content to allow into your life or your child’s life and what to avoid?
  • What are some ways you seek to glorify God even in your choice of entertainment?
  • How do you intentionally filter themes in fiction through a biblical lens?

engage

  • How can Christian parents help their children learn to guard against inappropriate secular content?
  • How can we help one another navigate differences of conscience when it comes to books and movies like Harry Potter(Romans 14)?
  • How can we use stories to have conversations about Christ and biblical truths?